Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Selection of effective formwork system using multi criteria decision making analysis

Dhanasekar Palanisamy, Umarani C, Renuka S M

Abstract


Formwork is the largest single cost item in constructing cast-in place reinforced concrete structure. This project focuses on analyzing the formwork selection problem based on decisive criteria. The factors affecting the choice of the exact formwork system have been often discussed in literatures but their importances have not been distinctly formulated. Therefore, a survey was conducted to recognize the decisive criteria in the formwork selection problems and ranking of the factors were carried out. A questionnaire formulated using google forms was sent to several respondents through email.74 responses were received and used for data analysis. The survey considered three types of currently used formwork systems with eight decisive criteria that affect the choice of formwork selection. Based on the 74 responses, the mean values for each decisive criterion were determined. Several methods that can be easily applied to solve the problem of formwork selection were identified. One of them is the TOPSIS (Technique for Order Performance by Similarity and Ideal Solution) algorithm, which is an easy to understand tool and can compute the best choice from the various alternatives of formwork system. Decisive criterion weights of mean values were calculated, and their weightage ordering was done by using Rank exponent method. Based on the ranking of decisive criteria, problems were discussed and suggestions were given to the respective problems. This project is concluded with comparing the results obtained from TOPSIS technique to responses from experienced site personnel in the construction industries and various suggestions in the formwork system were presented.

Full Text:

PDF

References


REFERENCES

Emad Elbeltagi, (2011), “Selection of slab formwork system using fuzzy logic”Construction Management and Economics, vol.29, pp 659-670.

Swapnali M. Karke, M.B. Kumathekar “Comparison ofthe use of Traditional and Modern Formwork Systems”,Civil Engineering Systems and Sustainable Innovations, ISBN: 978-93-83083-78-7.

Elbeltagi E.E, O.A. Hosny, A. Elhakeem, M.E. Abdelrazek, M.S. El-Abbasy, Fuzzylogic model for selection of vertical formwork systems, J. Constr. Eng. Manage.138 (7) (2012) 832–840.

C.M. Tam et al., “Selection of vertical formwork system by probabilistic neural networks model”,Management and Economics 23, 2005, pp. 245-254.

Karke, S.M. and Kumathekar, M.B 2014, Comparison of the use of Traditional and ModernFormwork Systems, in Civil Engineering Systems and Sustainable Innovations, G.C. Mishra,Editor., EXCELLENT PUBLISHING HOUSE: New Delhi, India. p. 348-351.

Kamarthi SV, Sanvido VE, Kumara SR. Neuroform – neural network system for vertical formwork selection. Computing in Civil Engineering1992;6(2):178–193

Dinesh p (2017) “analysis of effective selection of formwork system based on various factors for construction projects” international journal of advanced research trends in engineering and technology, vol. 4, no.11, pp 85-89.

A.S. Hanna, V.E. Sanvido, “Interactive vertical formwork selection system”, Concrete International 12(4),1990, pp. 26-32

A.S. Hanna, J.H. Willenbrock, V.E. Sanvido, “Knowledge acquisition and development for formworkselection system”, Journal of Construction Engineering and Management 118(1), 1992, pp. 179-198.

Ms. AakankshaDilip Chaudhary (2017) “Study of Tunnel Formwork System & Comparative Analysis with Conventional Formwork” International Journal of Scientific and Engineering Research 8(5) ,pp.1281-1286.

Hanna A.S. Concrete formwork system. Universityof Wisconsin – Madison. Marcel Dekker, Inc., NewYork. 1998, 269 p.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.