Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription or Fee Access

Bidding Strategy for Building Projects Based on Game Theory

M. Barath Priyan, K. Chinnaraju

Abstract


The owners of construction projects typically apply a competitive bid process to award a contract to the qualified bidder who submits the lowest price. For the contractors, it is very difficult to decide an optimal mark-up and bid value to win the contract and at the same time to secure sustaining profitability as high as possible. For that, from the various literatures related to the bidding problems, the factors are identified which may be highly influencing in the bidders’ de-cision-making during competitive situations in India. The factors are all converted into the question form, which was designed as single part. Then the questionnaire survey was conducted to the Class I and Class II type of Indian contractors to identify their opinions and strategies in the bidding. Then assessed the experts’ opinions consistency in order to neglect the general opinions from the experts. From the experts’ opinion, the least and high impact factors are identified. Then the collected data are converted into the probabilities and payoffs in order to apply in the game theory. From the payoff matrix applying of game theoretic approach, the best strategy was identified to follow the optimal bidding decisions. The founded strategies are plotted into the strategic model to guide the contractors by optimal mark-up size with respect to probability of winning and the competitive bid values. Finally, the project proposes a bidding decision model to assist contractors to select an optimal mark-up size and set appropriate bidding strategy under an extremely competition circumstances.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Friedman L. A competitive bidding strategy. J Oper Res. 1956; 4(04): 104–112p.

Gates M. Bidding strategies and probabilities. J Constr Eng Manag. 1967; 93(1): 75–115p.

Ahmad I, Minkarah I. Questionnaire survey on bidding in construction. J Manag Eng. 1988; 4(03): 229–243p.

Indian Contract Act 1872.

Wibowo MA, Astana INY, Rusdi HA. An analysis of bidding strategy, pro-ject performance and company per-formance relationship in construction. J Proc Eng. 2015; 125(6): 95–102p.

Ahmed MO, El-Adaway IH, Coatney K, Eid MS. Multi-stage bidding for construction contracts: a game theory approach. J Constr Eng Manag. 2015; 05(01): 19–26p.

Kembłowski MW, Grzyl B, Siemaszko A. Game theory analysis of bidding for a construction contract. In: IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and Engineering, Vol. 245. IOP Pub-lishing Ltd; 2017.

Astana NY, Rusdi HA, Wibowo MA. Factors affecting bidding strategy in construction. Austr J Basic Appl Sci. 2015; 9(5): 211–215p.

Oyeyipo O, Odusami KT, Ojelabi RA, Afolabi AO. Factors affecting con-tractors’ bidding decision for con-struction projects in Nigeria. J Constr Dev Countr. 2016; 10(4): 29–34p.

Prajapati R, Pitroda J, Bhavasar JJ. Analysis of factor affecting contrac-tor’s bidding strategy using RII method. Int J Mod Trends Eng Res. 2015; 02(04): 89–22p.

Wanous M, Boussabaine AH, Lewis J. To bid or not to bid: a parametric so-lution. J Constr Manag Econ. 2000; 18(04): 457–466p.

Xingli Y, Tingjie L. Analysis of bid strategy with game theory in auctions with a buyout price. International Conference on Service Systems and Service Management. 2007, June 9–11. 1-4244-0885/ IEEE.

White Z. Financial Performance Sur-vey of Architecture, Engineering, Planning & Environmental Consulting Firms. Survey in Japan. 2017.

Gui-Qin Z, Zhi-Fei X, Wei Z. Strategy research on bidding of construction project based on game theory. Inter-national Conference on Information Management and Engineering. 2011.

Aumann R. Interactive epistemology II: Probability. Int J Game Theory. 1999; 28: 301–3147p.

Levin J. Games of incomplete infor-mation. In: Textbook Introduction of Game Theory, Vol. 2.

Panneerselvam R. Operation Research, 2nd edition. Delhi: PHI Learning Limited; 2016.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.37628/ijce.v5i1.488

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.